Reading the Flags at Camperdown: How a Fleet Fought Through the Smoke, 1797

Battle of Camperdown by Samuel Drummond

A surviving record from HMS Triumph lets us read the Battle of Camperdown as a problem of communication. How did Admiral Adam Duncan tell a fleet under sail what to do before smoke, distance and damage broke up the view?

On 11 October 1797, two fleets met off the Dutch coast. The British commander, Admiral Adam Duncan, could see that Vice-Admiral Jan de Winter’s Dutch ships were getting nearer land. Duncan needed to turn his approach into an attack before the opportunity passed. His captains could not hear him. Even if they could see his flagship, HMS Venerable, they still had to recognise an order and work out how to carry it out from their own position.

Samuel Drummond’s painting of the Battle of Camperdown in 1797
Samuel Drummond, Battle of Camperdown, October 1797. Painted in 1827, three decades after the action. View the Historical Maritime print.

What the signal record actually tells us

Royal Museums Greenwich holds a list of signals made during the battle as recorded aboard HMS Triumph. That detail is valuable. It puts one surviving record on a ship that had to interpret orders, rather than on the flagship that issued them. Duncan’s dispatch supplies a different kind of evidence. It explains his intentions as commander, looking back on the action. A useful reading keeps those perspectives distinct: an admiral’s account of what he meant to happen, and a record made aboard one of the ships that had to act.

A flag hoist was visible language. It could communicate an agreed order across water without an officer having to carry instructions by boat. It still relied on someone spotting the hoist, making it out and knowing what it meant. Reading a signal was only the start. A captain had to judge how much sail he could safely carry, which opening he could reach, and whether a friendly ship was already moving towards it. HMS Triumph’s signal record at Royal Museums Greenwich.

Shorten sail, then break the line

Duncan recalled signalling his squadron to shorten sail as it drew near, so the ships could close up. That is a revealing detail in a battle often remembered for the charge. In a fleet under sail, ships do not all make equal speed. A vessel racing ahead can reach the enemy before the ships behind it can support it. Reducing sail could help the leading ships bring their pace back into step with the rest.

Duncan then saw land between Camperdown and Egmond and judged there was little time to lose. He ordered the ships to bear up, break the enemy’s line and engage on its leeward side. In this setting, the leeward side was towards the coast. Bearing up meant turning away from the wind. Breaking the line meant passing through openings between Dutch ships instead of following their line on the seaward side.

Those short instructions describe a considerable change of course. They tell a captain what the fleet is trying to achieve, but they cannot tell him which gap will still be open when he reaches it. The shape of the Dutch line, the speed of his own ship and the positions of other British vessels would determine that. Duncan’s account as reproduced in the contemporary press.

Robert Dodd print of the British fleet bearing down on the Dutch line at Camperdown
Robert Dodd, the British fleet bearing down at noon. The print’s caption identifies HMS Monarch as opening the action in the Dutch rear. Royal Collection image via Wikimedia Commons.

How to read the approach in Robert Dodd’s print

Start at the rear of the Dutch line, where the caption places Monarch, and work back towards the other approaching ships. The print gives you the broad view a lookout on a single warship would have lacked. It also makes clear why a common order did not produce identical actions everywhere. Each captain started from a different place and reached the line at a different time.

Try reading the image twice. On the first pass, follow the approach as a single movement. On the second, choose one ship and look at what lies directly ahead of it. Which ship could mask its view of the flagship? Which opening is it heading for? The print cannot answer every question about the manoeuvre, but the exercise gives a better feel for the job that fell to individual captains.

Robert Dodd’s afternoon view of Camperdown with the Dutch flagship dismasted
Robert Dodd, the Dutch fleet defeated in the afternoon. Compare the dismasted flagship here with the ordered approach in the noon plate. Royal Collection, via Wikimedia Commons.

The key that came with Dodd’s prints

Dodd’s opening view was one half of a pair issued in 1798. The second shows the Dutch defeat in the afternoon, with De Winter’s flagship dismasted and close to surrender. The Royal Collection also holds the printed key to both views. It is an unusually useful third object: the two pictures show what Dodd chose to put before the reader, while the key lets the reader check which ships and moments the pictures are intended to represent.

Begin with the noon view and find Monarch using the caption. Then open the afternoon view and find the dismasted flagship. Those are different points of focus because the story has moved from the first contact in the Dutch rear to the defeat of the flagship. A single canvas can make a battle feel like one simultaneous event. The paired prints give it a before and an after. They still organise events for a viewer at a safe distance, with the benefit of hindsight. View Dodd’s afternoon plate.

Robert Dodd’s engraved identification key for the two Camperdown battle prints
Robert Dodd’s key to the Camperdown prints, 1798. Royal Collection, RCIN 735057.c. Open the image to inspect the numbered details and explanatory text.

What a signal could ask of an individual ship

Imagine two British captains receiving the same order from different positions. One approaches an opening with enough room to turn after passing through. The other sees a friendly ship already making for the gap. The second captain has to leave enough room for that ship to clear, alter course or look for another opening. The signal gives both captains the same objective. Their view of the water ahead determines whether they can take the same route. This is an illustration of the decision involved, rather than a reconstruction of the orders given aboard two particular vessels.

A flag’s meaning was also only useful for as long as it could reach its audience. From the deck, a lookout might see enough to recognise the flagship’s rig without being able to distinguish a small flag against it. A sail could mask the hoist even before the guns began firing. As ships closed and turned, a line of sight that had existed a minute earlier could vanish. Dodd’s high viewpoint is useful precisely because it lets a reader see several ships at once. From any one of those decks, the problem would have looked different.

Bligh’s Director and the last broadside

Another example puts us on the far side of the manoeuvre. Royal Museums Greenwich holds a print after a watercolour by John Owen, depicting HMS Director firing as Vrijheid ceased to answer. The museum describes Director, under William Bligh, as one of the ships that continued the engagement after damage forced Duncan’s Venerable away. Compare this narrowly framed action with Dodd’s afternoon panorama. One records a particular ship’s part in the defeat, while the other makes it possible to place that event within the wider battle. View Director’s last broadside.

What happens when the flagship moves away?

Nicholas Pocock’s view takes us to a later stage. The Dutch flagship Vrijheid is dismasted near the centre, with Duncan’s Venerable to the right. Royal Museums Greenwich’s account of another image follows the action beyond that scene. After damage forced Venerable to sheer off, Vrijheid was engaged by Triumph, Ardent and Director. She lost her masts and eventually struck her colours.

The sequence is a good test of what signals could achieve. Duncan could order his ships to break through and engage. Once the fleets were mixed together, there was no guarantee that a ship which began a fight would remain in it, or that the flagship would stay where other captains expected to find her. Nearby ships could see a chance to continue the action and take it. Royal Museums Greenwich’s account of Director’s final broadside.

Nicholas Pocock’s view of the later action at Camperdown, with the dismasted Dutch flagship Vrijheid
Nicholas Pocock, The Battle of Camperdown, 11 October 1797. Compare the damaged ships and broken formation with Dodd’s image of the opening approach. National Maritime Museum image via Wikimedia Commons.

Why a painting and a signal list belong together

Drummond’s painting gives the battle scale and atmosphere. Dodd helps establish where the attack began. Pocock brings the eye back to the ships fighting around Vrijheid. The signal record and dispatch give those views a sequence. The first orders deal with the space between ships and the position of the enemy. The later pictures show why that tidy description was hard to sustain once the fighting was under way.

There is one more distinction worth keeping in mind. The flags that carry orders and the colours a ship strikes serve different purposes. The former tell other ships to do something. Lowering the colours communicates that a ship is surrendering. Both depend on being seen and understood, and both give the historian a way to follow decisions in a battle where what could be seen changed from minute to minute.

Daniel Orme’s painting of Admiral Duncan receiving Admiral de Winter’s surrender
Daniel Orme, Duncan Receiving the Surrender of de Winter. The deck-level view turns the fleet action into an encounter between two commanders. National Maritime Museum catalogue.

The signal the fleet could hear

A small object in the Greenwich collection tells a quieter story about the morning after battle. According to its catalogue, on 12 October HMS Monarch passed under the stern of Duncan’s flagship. A boatswain’s call gave the cue for three cheers, and the other ships took them up. The museum identifies the surviving call as the instrument used on that occasion.

The example is a useful contrast with the previous day’s flag hoists. A boatswain’s call could cue people within earshot, and the cheering could then pass from ship to ship. It carried a simple, unmistakable message. There was no need for a captain to consult a code or turn a hoist into a manoeuvre. The object also reminds us that the crews who had spent the previous day trying to keep sight of their flagship were still communicating after the guns fell quiet. View the Camperdown boatswain’s call.

What was Duncan’s order at Camperdown?

In his dispatch, Duncan described ordering his squadron to shorten sail as it closed, then to turn downwind, break through the Dutch line and engage from the leeward side. The order gave the fleet a common aim. Finding a passage and choosing how to engage were decisions each captain had to make from his own quarterdeck.