Would You Sail With This Map? Eight Charts and the Decisions Behind Them

A bird’s-eye view of Cartagena with its street grid, groups of ships in the harbour and an animal in a separate inset.

    Martinique is in sight. The mountains match the drawing, the island has a name, and the ship is heading for the right bay. Then the captain asks how much water is under the keel. Seven of the eight maps here would leave the pilot searching for another sheet.

    That question would have puzzled some of their makers. An atlas publisher in Antwerp wanted a reader to grasp the width of an ocean. A hydrographer working off Martinique might spend a morning measuring one small patch of it. Both had good reason to draw the same coast quite differently.

    Choosing a Destination

    The world on a library table

    Atlas frontispiece map · Antwerp, 1570

    An oval world map surrounded by clouds, with a large southern continent extending across the bottom.
    Ortelius World Map · View the map print

    Set a finger on Portugal and another on Brazil. Ortelius gives an Antwerp reader the Atlantic crossing in a single glance. His Theatrum Orbis Terrarum gathered maps by different hands into one printed volume. A reader could begin with this world map, turn to a regional sheet and examine the same country at a larger scale. Moving between those views was one of the pleasures of owning the book.

    On a ship the oval border would soon become a practical difficulty. Meridians curve towards it, so a straight pencil line between two ports does not give a compass course to follow. And while Brazil is easy to find, a harbour entrance takes up less space than the engraved line of the coast.

    The most telling feature is the enormous continent drawn across the south. Its coastline looks as firm as Portugal’s, though much of it was conjectural. An atlas owner could use the sheet to discuss the reach of a voyage. A pilot needed to know which stretches of coast anyone had actually seen.

    Brazil seen from the counting house

    Illuminated manuscript · Miller Atlas, 1519

    A painted coastline of Brazil with people working among trees on land and sailing ships offshore.
    Map of Brazil · View the map print

    The painted ships tell us how a visitor might reach Brazil. The figures among the trees tell us why a merchant might send a ship there. People fell and carry brazilwood, the source of a valuable red dye. Where a pilot might have wanted a drawing of a headland as it appeared from offshore, the illuminator has given the reader a view deep into the forest.

    Lopo Homem, Pedro and Jorge Reinel contributed to the atlas, with illumination by António de Holanda. The wealth of painted detail belongs to a costly manuscript intended for close inspection. Portuguese flags make claims about possession. The people cutting timber record, almost in spite of those flags, whose knowledge and labour made the trade possible.

    A coastal place name could be useful aboard ship. A master and pilot discussing a destination could point to the same stretch of shore. But a painted ship offshore is no recommendation of an anchorage. The page gives no comparable account of the bottom, the depth or the shelter a laden vessel might find there.

    Following a Coast

    A compass drawn across the water

    Manuscript nautical atlas · Lázaro Luís, 1563

    A manuscript chart with a network of compass lines at sea and painted buildings, hills and banners inland.
    Portuguese Nautical Chart · View the map print

    Choose any two headlands. Now look for a fine ruled line running in roughly the direction from one to the other. The web around the coast provides a set of compass directions for just this sort of comparison. The towers and banners catch the eye first, but the pilot’s interest lay in those quiet lines across the sea.

    This sheet belonged to a book. The catalogue of Spain’s Instituto Geográfico Nacional describes ten parchment leaves, including cosmographical material and calendars as well as charts. A reader could study the shape of a coast alongside the wider knowledge expected of a navigator. Its contents help explain the design even though we cannot say that a particular pilot took this leaf to sea.

    A compass direction was useful once the pilot knew the point of departure. The page could not establish that point for him. Two capes that look quite distinct from above can make much the same low silhouette from a moving deck. Misidentify the first and a perfectly good compass bearing starts from the wrong place.

    West Africa, cape by cape

    Manuscript nautical atlas · Fernão Vaz Dourado, Goa, 1571

    The West African coastline edged with small place names, with coloured flags inland and a compass rose offshore.
    Portuguese Nautical Chart · View the map print

    Dourado worked in Goa. Here, on a page made beside the Indian Ocean, a reader can follow the Atlantic coast of West Africa. Tilt your head as you read around the bend of the coast. The small names turn with the shoreline and sit close to the places they identify. They leave the sea comparatively clear for a reader following the compass lines.

    The atlas gathered knowledge from voyages too widely scattered for one mariner to have made them all. A pilot approaching a long coast could use this leaf to put capes, rivers and islands in sequence. Lookouts who recognised one landmark would know which to expect next. The large flags farther inland served a reader with another interest entirely, one concerned with allegiance and competing claims.

    Recognising the mouth of a river was only the first part of entering it. A bar of sand could lie beneath an apparently open channel. The pilot who had correctly followed the coast for hundreds of miles still had good reason to seek local knowledge for the last mile.

    Finding Manhattan on a sideways coast

    Printed regional atlas map · Willem Blaeu, about 1635

    A map of northeastern North America with ships offshore, animals inland and north towards the right.
    Map of New England and New York · View the map print

    Blaeu gave the long northeastern seaboard of North America room by turning it. North is to the right. Start from the ships in the Atlantic and work inland towards Long Island and Manhattan. From this angle it becomes easier to see what mattered to Dutch traders: the connection between an ocean crossing and a river journey into the interior.

    The map draws on the explorations of Adriaen Block and other Dutch traders. Their coastal knowledge reached print in Amsterdam, where atlas readers could trace connections between places without ever boarding a ship. The names Nova Belgica and Anglia Nova set Dutch and English claims beside one another. The settlements and waterways on the sheet belonged to a much older inhabited landscape.

    An arriving master could use the map to distinguish a journey up the Hudson from a passage along Long Island Sound. A choice between those two routes can be made at this scale. A choice between two channels around a shoal requires finer evidence. Turning the sheet to put north at the top changes neither its scale nor the knowledge it contains.

    Finding a Way In

    A harbour drawn after the ships came home

    Illustrated expedition account · Baptista Boazio, published 1589

    A bird’s-eye view of Cartagena with its street grid, groups of ships in the harbour and an animal in a separate inset.
    Sir Francis Drake in Cartagena · View the map print

    If this looks like a plan for an approaching fleet, the publication date gives the game away. Drake’s expedition occupied Cartagena in 1586. Boazio’s maps accompanied the printed True Discourse of the voyage. A reader in London could follow the ships into the harbour and relate the account to the town, three years after the event.

    The walls and street grid are seen from above. The ships turn their sides towards us so that their sails and hulls can be read. An enlarged animal even has a frame of its own. Boazio changes viewpoint and scale within one sheet to accommodate a reader curious about the place as well as the English victory.

    A captain who later visited Cartagena could learn the broad relation of town, harbour and enclosing land. The little ships would have been poor marks to steer towards. Their arrangement records an episode, and their size makes them visible in a book. Neither tells the pilot where deep water begins.

    An Arctic route still in question

    Polar map · Willem Barentsz, published 1598

    A polar map with lines radiating from the pole, compass roses, ships and sea creatures between the coasts.
    Map of Polar Regions · View the map print

    On Ortelius’s world map the far north is pressed against the frame. On Barentsz’s sheet the meridians gather at the pole. Trace the northern edge of Europe towards Asia and the attraction of a north-east passage is immediately intelligible. A shipowner considering the expense of another expedition had reason to want precisely this view.

    The map appeared the year after Barentsz died. On his final voyage his vessel had become trapped at Novaya Zemlya. The party spent the winter there, and he died on the return journey in 1597. The distinction between a coast that had been reached and a passage that could be sailed all the way through mattered keenly to the survivors.

    For another expedition, the sheet offered a way of comparing sightings and deciding which stretch of coast merited investigation. The hardest question was seasonal. Ice that admitted a ship on the outward leg could bar her return. No amount of space between two engraved shores could tell a captain how long that opening would last.

    Martinique and the last mile to shore

    Hydrographic survey chart · French Dépôt de la Marine, 1831

    An engraved chart of Martinique with shaded mountain ridges inland and depth figures along the coast.
    French Nautical Chart of Martinique · View the map print

    This chart has two histories, and the title gives the dates of both. Its land relief drew on surveys made in 1763–66. Its information about the waters around Martinique came from work undertaken in 1824–25 by the naval hydrographer Monnier, assisted by Le Bourguignon-Duperré. The ridges and the depth figures look as though they belong to a single sustained act of observation. Nearly sixty years separate the two surveys.

    A nineteenth-century mariner could use first one and then the other. The ridges helped identify which part of the island was coming into view. Nearer shore, the scattered figures gave measured depths, or soundings. A sailor could lower a weighted line from the vessel and compare the depth he found with the pattern printed around him. Several readings as the vessel moved were more informative than a single plausible match.

    The heading identifies this as a general chart of the island. In a confined anchorage the pilot would want a larger-scale harbour plan, the state of the tide and soundings from his own ship. Of the eight sheets, this one comes closest to answering the captain’s original question. Its most useful numbers were measurements someone else had already taken. The next one was for the crew to make.

    Catalogue notes and further reading