Who Owns a Captured Ship? The Strange Afterlife of a Naval Prize

The Capture of the Foudroyant by HMS Monmouth

    In 1758 a French warship named Foudroyant surrendered to the British. Twenty-four years later she sailed into Portsmouth with a captured French ship of her own. Even her name was the same. What had changed in the meantime was who owned her, who paid her sailors and whose orders her captain obeyed.

    It is easy to miss that second life in a marine painting. The artist has every reason to stop when a flag comes down. For the sailors who had to bring a damaged stranger into port, and for anyone hoping to be paid, surrender was only the beginning.

    What made a capture lawful?

    In the age of sail, a vessel seized at sea was called a prize. In British practice, taking physical possession gave the captors a claim. When a merchant vessel was brought in, an Admiralty prize court could examine the claim and hear anyone who contested it. Ship and cargo presented separate questions. A neutral merchant might own the bales in a hold even if an enemy subject owned the hull.

    This explains an otherwise curious feature of capture. Along with the ship, the captors took her papers. A bill of lading could establish who had shipped a consignment and where it was going. Letters could reveal who really owned it. Masters and crew were questioned. If the judge ordered the property restored, its owner could recover it. If the court condemned it as lawful prize, it could be sold. In this setting “condemned” meant a decision about ownership. A perfectly sound ship could be condemned.

    Prize money came out of the value realised. In British naval service the distribution followed rules that changed over time. Rank mattered, as did the number of people entitled to share. An ordinary seaman’s portion could be small even when the total in the newspaper looked impressive. A warship bought into the navy, a privateer taken by a mail packet and a slave ship seized under treaty each had a different story to tell.

    Jeune Richard  ·  Off Barbados · 1 October 1807

    A packet captain comes home

    Captain William Rogers Capturing Jeune Richard by Samuel Drummond
    Captain William Rogers Capturing Jeune Richard · View the fine art print

    The French captain died on his own deck. His surviving men were ordered below. That left William Rogers with two vessels to bring into Barbados and casualties aboard both. Drummond shows Rogers above a fallen man, with the forecastle of his mail packet visible behind him. The painting compresses the two decks into one scene. Once the ships drew apart, the shortage of hands must have been felt on each.

    In Falmouth, the home port of the packet service, the men received payments according to rank. Rogers received swords of honour and command of a new packet, Countess of Chichester. He spent years carrying the mail in her. The National Maritime Museum Cornwall can trace him as far as his house on Dunstanville Terrace, looking out over the anchorage. The records cited here leave the privateer in Barbados. They tell us much less about the French sailors who reached port as prisoners.

    Foudroyant  ·  Off Cartagena · 28 February 1758

    A ship won without a boat to take her

    The Capture of the Foudroyant by HMS Monmouth by Francis Swaine after Richard Paton
    The Capture of the Foudroyant by HMS Monmouth · View the fine art print

    When the French flagship struck her colours, HMS Monmouth could scarcely move a man across the water. None of her boats would float. Her captain, Arthur Gardiner, had been carried below with a wound to the head. Lieutenant Robert Carkett had taken his place. Another British ship, Swiftsure, arrived before the surrender. Gardiner died of his wound. These details give the distant ships in the painting a significance that its title, with its emphasis on Monmouth, can easily obscure.

    The prisoners and the ship took different paths. A Portsmouth chronology records that Foudroyant and another French prize, Orphée, reached Spithead in July with about a thousand prisoners between them. The men were lodged at Portchester Castle. Across the harbour, dockyard workers fitted the eighty-gun Foudroyant for British service. Their measured drawing survives at Greenwich. In 1782 she came into Portsmouth again, this time under John Jervis, bringing in the French Pégase.

    Désirée  ·  Dunkirk Roads · July 1800

    A cutter carries the wounded home

    Capture of La Désirée by Thomas Whitcombe
    Capture of La Désirée · View the fine art print

    Thomas Whitcombe painted the moon high above the ships and its reflection stretching out across the water. The water itself was what worried the men bringing Désirée out. Lieutenant Pierce got the captured frigate under sail and across the banks. In his report, Commander Patrick Campbell reckoned the passage would have been impossible half an hour later. The British kept the frigate, which entered the Royal Navy as HMS Desiree.

    Some of her people crossed the same water in the other direction. Captain Henry Inman sent a British cutter into Dunkirk under a flag of truce with wounded French officers and sailors. The French reply thanking him survives alongside his letter in The Naval Chronicle. The correspondence supplies a second ending to Whitcombe’s night scene. For the injured men in the cutter, the important destination was a French port within sight of where they had been captured.

    Ambuscade  ·  Bay of Biscay · 14 December 1798

    The prize tows her captor

    Capture of HMS Ambuscade by Louis-Philippe Crépin
    Capture of HMS Ambuscade · View the fine art print

    Crépin brings the two vessels so close that their rigging is difficult to disentangle by eye. What happened when they finally came apart is more surprising still. The French corvette Bayonnaise had lost her masts. Her surviving men put the captured British frigate to work towing their own ship home. On 16 December the pair reached the Île d’Aix, on the approach to Rochefort, with the prize in front.

    Both commanders were wounded. The French commander, Edmond Richer, lost an arm. The British captain, Henry Jenkins, faced a court martial for losing his ship. He was acquitted, although the court criticised the conduct of the officers and men. French sailors meanwhile served aboard the frigate under the name Embuscade. The British recovered her in 1803. Her return to the Navy List is easy to trace. It tells us little about when each of the men taken in 1798 returned home.

    Ceylon  ·  Off Bourbon, now Réunion · September 1810

    Prisoners for a matter of hours

    Capture of Ceylon by La Vénus by Unknown Artist
    Capture of Ceylon by La Vénus · View the fine art print

    Small boats pass between the damaged frigates in this anonymous view. For Captain Charles Gordon of HMS Ceylon, the passage between ships meant captivity. He and Major-General John Abercromby, a passenger, were taken aboard the French flagship Vénus. Frenchmen went aboard Ceylon and an attempt was made to tow her away. The tow parted. By daylight the ships were still within reach of the British squadron at Bourbon.

    When HMS Boadicea intervened on 18 September, the British recovered Ceylon and captured Vénus. Gordon and Abercromby regained their liberty. French commodore Jacques Hamelin became a prisoner aboard the very squadron he had hoped to elude. His frigate went into British service as HMS Nereide. One can read the print’s title, Capture of Ceylon by La Vénus, quite literally. It describes the ships and their people for the short interval before their positions were reversed.

    Veloz Passagera  ·  West Africa and Freetown · September–October 1830

    A judgment with names behind the numbers

    Capture of the Veloz Passagera by Unknown Artist
    Capture of the Veloz Passagera · View the fine art print

    The two vessels in this print are far enough away for their sails to fill more space than their crews. The commissioners’ report from Sierra Leone brings individuals back into view. After HMS Primrose intercepted the Spanish slave ship on 7 September, the wounded master, Jozé Antonio de la Vega, was taken aboard the British vessel for treatment. The commissioners reported that many of the Spanish crew were given a boat and provisions and sent towards land. The mate, Alexandro Nocetty, and the gunner, Juan Bermudez, stayed to give evidence in October.

    On 16 October the British and Spanish commissioners condemned the vessel and decreed the emancipation of 529 survivors. Sixteen captive Africans had died on the passage to port and five more between arrival and judgment. A separate order concerned one person taken aboard Primrose for medical care. When the commissioners pronounced judgment, they did not know whether that person was still alive.

    One surviving register entry gives the name Muddy. It can be read alongside the judgment, which calls the ship Veloz Pasagera. Both documents were written for officials. They preserve a name and a legal change of status, but neither tells us where Muddy wished to go, whether family survived the crossing, or what freedom meant in the years that followed.

    Reading beyond the surrender

    A dockyard drawing answers the question of what became of Foudroyant. A second encounter changes the ending of Ceylon’s story. For the people aboard Veloz Passagera, we have to put the picture aside and open a register. Each is a reason to linger over a naval painting after we have worked out who won.

    Sources and further reading